Language: English Language: Chinese Language: French Language: German Language: Japanese Language: Spanish

Purpose and Audience of the Judge McElrea Restorative Justice Collection

Purpose of the Collection: Spreading Good News – and Further Reform

The purpose of the collection is to gather all McElrea’s work in one place and make it as accessible, prominent, organised and reader- and researcher-friendly as possible. At the times of writing them over some 20 years, McElrea composed each paper for a specific occasion or forum, mostly by invitation. But he already had a unifying purpose. That was to spread the good news of restorative justice – and to dispel myths about it (like that it entirely replaces retribution or does away with all need for prisons), while also discussing its limits and risks. He was publicising what he saw to be the far more effective and human model of justice that it offers communities, offenders and especially victims. The papers have also set out ways to raise the standards of restorative justice as its many forms have proliferated across New Zealand and around the world.

McElrea’s ultimate hope was, and is, to make restorative justice, rather than court, the automatic or “default” option, at least wherever offenders admit wrongdoing. Criminal courts would remain for supervision, backstop and wherever defendants plead Not Guilty. Where a case goes to court, judges would try it as usual and, in the event of a Guilty finding, draw on the legislated range of sentencing options, including prisons – although the papers also touch on the many compelling reasons for minimising such recourse.

To that end of advocating a default restorative approach, some of the papers also detail McElrea’s proposal for Community Justice Centres, or Community Resolution Centres. These would provide a dedicated forum for the systematic introduction of restorative conferences for adults; adult conferencing so far lacks the infrastructure and legislative backing that has characterised the Family Group Conferences which New Zealand led the world in legislating for youths (14- to 16-year-olds). If accompanied by proper education and funding, the proposal for Community Justice Centres/Community Resolution Centres could revolutionise criminal justice in New Zealand and – perhaps – the UK and other parts of the English-speaking or “common law” world, which, like New Zealand, largely inherited the adversarial-punitive English model of courts and punishments.

Audience for the Collection: Everyone Interested in Justice – Plus Specialists ... and Sceptics!

Every citizen with an interest in justice will get something out of this collection. This goes doubly if you live in a common law country. But most papers assume no knowledge of either restorative justice or the traditional common law criminal justice system. And McElrea’s straight-talking style is all the more accessible precisely because many papers were speeches, and often to lay audiences, including community groups, victim support groups, marae, churches, even school prize-givings.

As the Complete Overview and Synopsis Table shows, other papers addressed specialists. Such papers detailed cutting-edge developments in restorative justice, and critiques of the adversarial-punitive system, for audiences of lawyers, judges, restorative justice practitioners, academics, policy makers, legislators and reformers. If they are like us, then legal professionals will find much here that is new and surprising. The surprises start with the rather unplanned history of the adversarial court system we take for granted and the punishments it metes out. Lawyers also get a rare insight into how a sitting judge navigated law reform, and thus the boundary between government’s judicial and legislative branches.

Finally, if you’re sceptical of restorative justice, the papers acknowledge common critiques of it and address many head-on in a way we hope will provoke further thought.

 → Go back to the McElrea restorative justice home page


Member Login

Events Calendar

Suggestion for Purchase

Featured Database

Featured Resource

Gale Science In Context
Science in Context features authoritative information for assignments and projects, and provides detailed coverage of popular subjects. From earth science and life science, to space, technology, mathematics and science history and biography, this revolutionary curriculum-oriented online experience is designed to boost achievement for students and researchers.
» read more

Catalogue Search

Library Catalogue

Quick search for books, DVDs, CDs, Magazines etc. Napier Libraries have a large collection at our Taradale and Napier libraries.

Advanced Search

Become a Friend



Positive progress on remedial building work
We are currently anticipating that public areas of the library will be open by the end of March or early April.
» read more
Hop on the buses! We're partnering with GoBay Buses to get you to Taradale Library.
Have your library card ready and travel from Napier to Taradale return for free.
» read more

Napier Libraries is one of Napier City Council's great facilities/services. There are many more...

Parklands Residential Estate

Located in the Art Deco city of Napier. We have worked closely with our builders to promote and develop high quality housing within an open-aspect environment.
View website for Parklands Residential Estate

Napier i-SITE Visitor Centre

Visit the Napier i-SITE to find out more about what is happening in Hawkes Bay, from events, activities and accommodation.
View website for Napier i-SITE Visitor Centre

The Faraday Centre

The Faraday Centre in Napier, is Hawke's Bay's Museum of Technology. It's a place of discovery where history comes alive through hands on experience.
View website for The Faraday Centre

Napier Municipal Theatre

Unique Art Deco heritage has been preserved with the skilful addition of modern theatre facilities making it the best provincial performing arts centre in the nation.
View website for Napier Municipal Theatre

Kennedy Park Resort Napier

We are Hawkes Bay's premier holiday accommodation park providing an array of facilities to keep the entire family entertained.
View website for Kennedy Park Resort Napier

Napier Conference Centre

We offer an all purpose built venue that uniquely combines spectacular outlooks with functional layout.
View website for Napier Conference Centre

MTG Hawke's Bay

Comprising a Museum, Theatre and Gallery - MTG is home to a significant collection of objects that form the foundation of distinctive exhibitions, a world-class research facility and the MTG Theatre.
View website for MTG Hawke's Bay

Napier Aquatic Centre

Situated in the centre of Napier, in the middle of Onekawa Park, the Napier Aquatic Centre is a safe and affordable aquatic facility for everyone.
View website for Napier Aquatic Centre

Par2 MiniGolf

Come to Par2 MiniGolf and meet Seamore the Seagull at our sea-side minigolf courses. Challenge your friends and family for a round.
View website for Par2 MiniGolf

Napier City Council

For Napier City residents and citizens to have easy access to see what council are currently working on, completed, what they do, facilities, and council information.
View website for Napier City Council

National Aquarium of New Zealand

Nowhere else in New Zealand will you discover a wider range of marine animals and native species in a single facility than at the National Aquarium of New Zealand.
View website for National Aquarium of New Zealand

Bay Skate

Located on Marine Parade, Napier, is the Bay Skate Park - home to skateboarding, BMX, roller derby, inline hockey and scootering.
View website for Bay Skate

Enquiry or Feedback

If you have any questions, problems or feedback for Napier Libraries please let us know about it.

Fill out my online form.

Follow Napier Libraries on facebook...